Imitation is said to be the sincerest form of flattery, but to the collector it can also be a huge stumbling block.
Whether intentionally, or due to a lack of experience, eBay, Etsy and the other popular online shops are filled with pieces represented as “antique” that are, in actuality, new merchandise. While it is not as commonplace in shops and malls, misrepresentation is still present. Always proceed with a “buyer beware” attitude and do your homework before you lay down your hard earned cash. Here are some tips on four commonly reproduced collectibles.
Depression glass — This colorful mass-produced glass made in the U.S. from 1930 through the mid-1940s is widely reproduced. Adam, Cherry Blossom and Sharon are the most commonly reproduced patterns. Warning signs include: variation in color, clarity of the pattern and the size of the piece. An easy way to identify a fake is to check the seams. They will always be present on authentic Depression glass, but seldom if ever on reproduction. Also look for “Straw marks.” These ripply little lines will appear on the bottom of most old glass, but never on new.
Enamelware — The current trend in Farm Fresh home decor has seen a resurgence in popularity of many primitives including enamelware. Early pieces were manufactured in America from 1870-1930 and resumed production again in the 1960s. Pieces from both eras are collectible. More recently there has been an onset of import from China. These are the pieces you will find for sale at home decor shops like Hobby Lobby. Older enamelware will be much heavier and smoother than their modern counterparts and will feature riveted handles and spouts.
Cast iron toys and banks — Old cast iron is very smooth to the touch while repros will be rough and may even have small holes or pits on the surface. If the piece has a seam it will fit very tightly on older iron while newer pieces will often have a considerable gap. Often toys and banks were painted. The older ones were dipped while newer issues were sprayed. Sprayed iron is prone to chipping with the passage of time. If the paint is perfect, you are probably looking at a repro. Unpainted old iron will be very dark brown or black while newer cast iron will be more gray in appearance.
Furniture — From the Indonesian reproduction “French” antiques of the late 1990s to the “old wood, new construction” Farm House furniture of 2018, furniture is a big ticket item and one area where your lack of knowledge can cost you a great deal of money. There is nothing wrong with purchasing a reproduction piece. Many of them are well made, attractive and will enhance your home for years to come. To know the difference will take time and study. In the meanwhile, deal only with reputable experienced dealers and auctions where you can trust the pros to tell the difference for you. Until next time . . . Linda
Linda Kennett is a professional liquidation consultant specializing in down-sizing for seniors and the liquidation of estates and may be reached at 317-258-7835 or lkennett@indy.rr.com