This column originally
appeared in Feb. 2013.
Last week I told you about Vincennes, Indiana native Buck Jones. One of the best known cowboy stars in Hollywood history, Buck died tragically in a nightclub fire during World War II. Not just any fire, but the Cocoanut Grove inferno in Boston, Massachusetts; the worst nightclub disaster in world history. Four hundred ninety two people perished while another 166 were injured.
Sadly, Buck Jones and the story of the Cocoanut Grove are largely forgotten nowadays. Buck Jones was one of the greatest of the “B” western stars and “The Grove” was THE place to be in Boston in 1942. The Cocoanut Grove was designated as a Restaurant/Supper Club because nightclubs did not officially exist in Boston. It was built in 1927 and located at 17 Piedmont St., a narrow cobblestoned street near the Park Square theater district in downtown Boston, Massachusetts.
Prohibition made the Cocoanut Grove very popular in the late 1920s, but it had fallen on hard times during the 1930s. Buck Jones was one of the greatest stars of the Silent film era in the 1920s but the coming of talking pictures in 1927 hurt his career and the Great Depression brought Buck’s career to a grinding halt. Boston was a major port of debarkation for troops shipping out for Europe in World War II and The Grove was riding a wave of resurgence in the early 1940s. Buck’s career took off again after signing a contract with Columbia Pictures in 1940. Soon the fates of Buck Jones and the Cocoanut Grove would be entwined once more.
It was November 28, 1942, two days after Thanksgiving, Buck Jones was in Boston on a combination war bond selling tour and promotional junket for his latest movie, White Eagle Riders of Death Valley. The day before, Buck phoned his wife, Odille, to tell her he’d caught a cold on his cross-country tour. Although not feeling well, upon arriving in Boston, Buck refused to cancel his appearances for fear that he would disappoint the children who expected to see him that Saturday.
Buck visited a children’s hospital that morning and went from there to Boston Garden for a rally of about 12,000 children. In a drizzling rain that afternoon Buck and a his group watched the Boston College-Holy Cross football game from the Mayor’s box. The schedule called for Buck and his entourage to meet at the Buddies’ Club USO on Boston Common at 9:30 p.m. to mix and mingle with the servicemen for a couple of hours. Buck begged off due to his cold. An impromptu testimonial dinner had been arranged for Buck at the Cocoanut Grove by a local theatre. Although ill, Buck attended out of courtesy to the distributors honoring him.
The Cocoanut Grove was a squat one-and-a-half-story block long building with a basement. The basement contained a bar, called the Melody Lounge, along with the kitchen, freezers, and storage areas. The first floor contained a large dining room area and ballroom with a bandstand, along with several bar areas separate from the ballroom. The dining room also had a retractable roof for use during warm weather to allow a view of the moon and stars. The main entrance to the Cocoanut Grove was via a revolving door on the Piedmont Street side of the building. The club featured a Polynesian motif with fake palm trees. Its walls and ceiling were bedecked with colored cloth. In the main room, rope braiding ran up several poles, topped with artificial palm leaves and coconuts.
Buck Jones and his group entered the Cocoanut Grove amid applause and fanfare from the guests. After accommodating the many handshakes and autograph requests, the celebrity entourage finally settled at tables on the mezzanine overlooking the dance floor. It was 10 p.m., and a band was playing in the lounge downstairs. The lounge was unusually dark after a bulb had been pulled from its socket, allegedly by an amorous couple desiring privacy. A 16-year-old bar boy named Stanley Tomaszewski, was ordered by his bartender boss to replace the bulb. While awkwardly standing atop a chair in the darkness, Stanley lit a match to screw in the bulb.
Within seconds, the open flame jumped to a nearby palm tree and ignited the palm fronds above the tables. The bartenders tried in vain to extinguish the fire with water and seltzer bottles. The cloth ceiling quickly caught fire and flames exploded upstairs almost instantaneously, spreading choking smoke and heat everywhere. It was a textbook flash fire.
At first, no one panicked as the crowd made their way slowly up the wide stairs. That is, until they saw the main entrance, a single revolving door jammed shut by bodies pressed against it. Just then a girl, her hair ablaze, ran from the Melody Lounge in the basement where the fire had begun, screaming ‘Fire!’ Panic set in. Flames flashed with incredible swiftness and smoke was thick as fog in the hallways. Blazing draperies fell, setting clothes and hair on fire. Soldiers in uniform called on everyone to remain calm, but they were drowned out by the screams of the patrons. Flames moved upstairs to the main bar, dance floor and dining room within 5 minutes.
In a strange twist of fate, at 10:15 p.m., the Boston Fire Department received a call about a car fire at Stuart and Carver Streets, about three blocks from the Cocoanut Grove. The firefighters responded and quickly extinguished the automobile fire. One of the firefighters saw smoke coming from the direction of the Cocoanut Grove. As they walked towards the club to investigate, panicked bystanders ran towards them screaming “Fire, Fire.” The firefighters saw fire and heavy smoke pouring from the building and patrons and employees fleeing from the building. By 10:25 p.m., the entire Boston Fire department was on the way to the scene.
Fire Department officials told of body-clogged doorways when they arrived on the scene. The dead and injured were piled in heaps. Nearly 200 people died in one ghastly mound behind the revolving door. The Grove had other exits, but most were locked to prevent patrons from leaving without paying while others, which only opened inward, were blocked by the panicked crowd. Reports persisted that some doors were locked to prevent entry/exit by non-paying customers.
Some escaped through the kitchen, but the toxic smoke became so thick that patrons couldn’t breathe, let alone see, and most simply died where they fell. Many patrons huddled under tables and dozens were trampled to death. Their bodies blocked the six-foot-wide stairway up from the lounge. A plate-glass window that might have provided egress was found to be boarded up. There were an estimated 800 to 1,000 people in the Grove that night (25 percent beyond capacity), all of whom were thrown into a hellish bedlam attempting to get out of the flaming, choking inferno.
The first firemen on scene were forced to crawl over the bodies of trapped victims before they could get inside. Police investigators found evidence that a terrific fight had taken place in the panicking darkness; the police chief stating, “Many of the bodies were actually torn apart.” Outside there were bodies piled everywhere, living and dead. The firemen doused them with freezing water to quench the flames.
When the magnitude of the disaster was realized, an urgent call for help was issued. Navy, Army, Coast Guard and National Guard personnel were called in to assist in the evacuation and removal of the injured. Newspaper delivery trucks, taxis, and city buses were used to transport the injured. In an interesting twist of fate, area hospitals had practiced a disaster drill the week before the fire. Although this practice is common today, it was quite innovative for 1942. A temporary morgue was established in a film distribution garage near the Grove. Several of those presumed dead were sent directly to the local morgue only to spring up from the table very much alive. They were moved to the hospital and survived with a whopper of a story to tell for the rest of their charmed lives.
Where was Buck Jones in this fiery melee? What is known is that Buck’s badly burned body was found by a Coast Guardsman and a taxi driver on the floor inside the club. Survivors lost their identities while recuperating in Mass General hospital, and doctors took to referring to them instead as “Patient 28” or “Case 36.” His body had been so badly burned in the fire that skin from his fingers had been pulled off and fused onto the fingerprint card sent to the FBI for identification. It took nearly 48 hours to identify the prints.
Almost immediately, rumors began to circulate that Buck Jones, the battle-scarred Army veteran, 101 Ranch Cowboy, Indianapolis Motor Speedway riding mechanic, Hollywood stuntman and cowboy hero of the silver screen, received his grievous burns while repeatedly returning into the burning building to save lives. No one can say for certain exactly what transpired in the bedlam of the 12-15 minute disaster. However, in the ensuing years many reports and stories have survived testifying to Buck’s heroism while leading trapped victims to safety and returning at least twice to the raging inferno to help others.
Buck was horribly burned and transferred to Mass General hospital where he died a few days later on Monday November 30th, the 481st person of 492 victims of that inferno. The autopsy noted that Buck Jones died of critical second and third degree burns to the face, mouth, neck and throat and smoke inhalation. He would have been 51 years old 2 weeks later on December 12th. Buck Jones, idol of millions of movie fans, Patient 224 died alone in an upstairs room at Massachusetts General Hospital while his wife Dell rushed to his bedside. She did not arrive in time to say goodbye. Buck Jones remains were cremated and his ashes were scattered in the Pacific Ocean, near Catalina Island.
Al Hunter is the author of the “Haunted Indianapolis” and co-author of the “Haunted Irvington” and “Indiana National Road” book series. His newest books are “Bumps in the Night. Stories from the Weekly View,” “Irvington Haunts. The Tour Guide,” and “The Mystery of the H.H. Holmes Collection.” Contact Al directly at Huntvault@aol.com or become a friend on Facebook.
